Contents
Dental Amalgam Fillings: All About This Controversial Material
Dental amalgam fillings are a traditional technique for treating cavities. But are they still relevant today? If you've ever had a significant cavity, it's likely your dentist placed an amalgam filling, also known as a "silver filling." This durable material, widely used for over 150 years, has become the subject of heated debate due to its mercury content. This guide explores everything you need to know about dental amalgam fillings, their advantages, risks, and modern alternatives.
What Exactly Is a Dental Amalgam Filling?
When a tooth is damaged by a cavity, the dentist must fill the space after removing the decayed tissue. Dental amalgam is a stable alloy created by combining elemental mercury (about 50%) with a mixture of other metals, primarily silver, tin, and copper. This combination creates a strong, durable, and inexpensive filling material that has been a staple in dentistry for decades.
The Health Controversy: What Are the Risks of Mercury?
The primary controversy surrounding amalgam fillings is their mercury content. Mercury is a known neurotoxin, and fillings can release low levels of mercury vapor, especially when chewing. However, major health organizations, including the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) and the American Dental Association (ADA), have extensively reviewed the scientific evidence and concluded that the low levels of mercury exposure from amalgam fillings are not harmful to the general population.
As a precaution, the FDA has updated its recommendations, advising that certain high-risk groups should avoid getting amalgam fillings whenever possible. These groups include:
- Pregnant women and their developing fetuses.
- Women who are planning to become pregnant.
- Nursing women and their newborns.
- Children, especially those under the age of six.
- People with pre-existing neurological disease or kidney impairment.
- People with a known allergy to mercury or other components of amalgam.
Pros and Cons of Amalgam Fillings: A Balanced Look
Advantages:
- Durability: Extremely strong and long-lasting, often for 15 years or more.
- Strength: Can withstand heavy chewing forces, making it ideal for molars.
- Cost-Effective: The most affordable direct filling material.
Disadvantages:
- Poor Aesthetics: The silver color does not match natural teeth.
- More Tooth Removal: Often requires the removal of more healthy tooth structure to create a secure hold.
- Mercury Content: Contains mercury, which is a concern for some patients.
- Temperature Sensitivity: Can cause temporary sensitivity to hot and cold.
Modern Alternatives to Amalgam Fillings
Today, there are several excellent mercury-free alternatives to amalgam:
- Composite Resin: A tooth-colored plastic and glass mixture that is bonded directly to the tooth. It's the most popular alternative for its excellent aesthetics and conservative nature.
- Glass Ionomer Cement: A tooth-colored material that releases fluoride, which can help prevent recurrent decay. It is not as strong as composite resin.
- Porcelain or Ceramic Inlays/Onlays: Lab-fabricated restorations that are highly aesthetic and durable but also more expensive.
The Price of Dental Fillings: Amalgam vs. Composite
The cost of a filling depends on the size of the cavity and the material used. In the US, an amalgam filling for one or two surfaces typically costs between $50 and $150, while a composite filling for the same tooth might cost between $90 and $250. Fillings are generally considered a "basic" restorative service and are covered by most dental insurance plans at around 80% after the deductible.
Should You Have Your Old Amalgam Fillings Removed?
Both the FDA and the ADA currently advise against removing amalgam fillings that are in good condition ("intact"). The removal process can release a higher amount of mercury vapor than leaving the filling in place. It also requires the removal of additional healthy tooth structure, potentially weakening the tooth. Removal is only recommended if the filling is worn, broken, or if there is decay underneath it.
Conclusion: An Informed Decision
Despite the controversy, dental amalgam remains a safe, effective, and economical solution for treating cavities in non-high-risk populations. However, with the excellent aesthetic and conservative properties of modern composite resins, amalgam is used far less frequently today. The most important step is to discuss all options with your dentist to choose the best material for your specific health needs and goals. The ultimate key to avoiding this decision is preventing cavities in the first place through good daily oral hygiene.
FAQ: Your Top Questions About Amalgam Fillings
No, dental amalgam is not banned in the United States. The FDA considers it safe and effective for the general population. However, its use has significantly declined in favor of more aesthetic composite resins, and the FDA has issued specific recommendations advising against its use in certain high-risk groups.
Amalgam fillings are known for their exceptional durability. On average, they last about 10 to 15 years, but it's not uncommon for them to last much longer. Composite fillings have an average lifespan of 5 to 10 years, though modern materials are continually improving their longevity.
SMART stands for Safe Mercury Amalgam Removal Technique. It is a set of safety protocols established by the International Academy of Oral Medicine and Toxicology (IAOMT) for dentists who remove amalgam fillings. It involves using high-volume suction, a rubber dam, and special air filtration to minimize mercury vapor exposure for both the patient and the dental team during the removal process.